Last-minute announcement by Hinshaw shocks parents

Over the weekend--just two days before schools in Alberta were set to re-open--chief medical officer of health Dr. Hinshaw dropped an announcement that shocked many parents and teachers.

Ministerial Order 33-2020 stipulates that masks and two-meter social distancing will not be mandatory in classrooms.

There was immediate outrage from parents and teachers who had been given the impression by previous statements from the government that masks would be used in all schools. The announcement came so close to school re-opening--past the deadline for enrolling students somewhere else--that many parents online complained of a bait-and-switch.

Dr. Hinshaw responded at a press conference on Monday, arguing that the ministerial order was consistent with policies that had already been announced weeks ago, and that the lateness of the announcement was due to delays in “legal processes.”

There is of course no magical power inherent to desks that make kids virus-immune while seated. It’s hard not to see this as an admission that two-meter distancing is simply impossible when dealing with classes of 35, 40, or more students packed into one room.

David Climenhaga has a thorough write-up of the whole situation over at, and I agree with his analysis: the Kenney administration’s re-opening plan is sloppy, it wasn’t communicated clearly to the public, and we’re all at risk of a second coronavirus surge because of it.

In contrast to the provincial government’s cavalier approach to the school re-opening the federal government announced last week that it would transfer two billion dollars in funding to the provinces to help pay for COVID safety measures in schools. Education Minister Adriana LaGrange has still not announced how Alberta’s share of this funding will be used.

AB fiscal update about as bad as you’d expect

Last week the Kenney administration presented the fiscal update, the regular report on the province’s finances. The situation is about as bad as you might expect--though perhaps not as bad as the UCP government and certain voices in the media are making it out to be.

Even before coronavirus Alberta was struggling with high unemployment thanks to a global market that just wasn’t very interested in our bitumen oil. Government revenue was already quite low thanks to Alberta’s low taxes and royalty rates; the UCP had just announced a gigantic corporate tax cut ($4.7 billion on paper, though we know now that it’s amounting to much more than that); and the provincial budget was based on oil price estimates that were already unrealistic the day the document was typed up. (Finance Minister Toews actually told us with a straight face that he expected our bitumen oil to be selling for $58 a barrel this year!) 

Then the virus hit, and economic activity worldwide ground to a near-halt.

The result is Alberta’s largest budget deficit in history, at $24.4 billion this year--triple what Minister Toews predicted in the budget.

The UCP government is sure to use this enormous figure as an excuse both to slash public services and to implement even more hair-brained ‘job creator’ tax cuts. But it’s worth noting that despite this bad year, Alberta’s debt situation is actually quite mild. By the end of the year Alberta’s debt, as a percentage of its GDP (a rough metric of economic activity), will be just above British Columbia’s in the low 20s--less than half that of all of the provinces east of Saskatchewan. The sky is not falling, and this deficit is not an excuse to start selling off our schools, parks, and hospitals. But it’s certainly long past time that those with wealth in Alberta started paying their fair share to keep this province running.


This is the online version of the Progress Report email newsletter. Don't depend on some social media or search engine algorithm to find this content in the future. Sign up to get the best left wing political newsletter in your inbox every Tuesday